SEO, Google Ads and WordPress for London, Kitchener-Waterloo, Windsor and the rest of the 519519WebDesignca@gmail.com
Free SEO audit

Why did my traffic drop? The four causes

The four causes we see most, in order of how often: a spam-link attack, redirect loops or lost pages after a rebuild, Google switching which of your pages ranks for a search, and thin or duplicate pages. All four show up in Google Search Console, which is where we start.

1. A spam-link attack

Thousands of links from link farms, often with foreign-language anchors, pointing at your site. You did not buy them; someone pointed them at you, or an old vendor did. Search Console’s Links report and Ahrefs or Semrush show them. The fix is a disavow file built from a verified link pull. Across the sites we work on we have disavowed 2,227 spam domains so far, 427 of them on one tobacco store that then went from 33 to 214 clicks a month.

2. Redirect loops and lost pages after a rebuild

A new site with new addresses and no redirects from the old ones. Or redirects that chain and loop. Search Console’s Pages report lists them as “Page with redirect” and “Not found”. The fix is a redirect map from every old address to its new page.

3. Google switched which page ranks

Two of your pages target the same search. Google picks one, then the other, and the ranking jumps around. Search Console’s Performance report, filtered to the search, shows two URLs trading places. The fix is one page per search, and the other page pointed at it.

4. Thin or duplicate pages

Hundreds of near-identical pages: tag archives, filtered category pages, name-swapped town pages. Google indexes them, then stops trusting the site. The fix is to remove or noindex them and rewrite the ones worth keeping. On one tobacco store we cut the sitemap from 313 URLs to 208 and removed a duplicate H1 from 104 of 120 posts.

What we check first

The date the drop started against Google’s update dates. Which pages and which searches lost clicks. The Links report. The Pages report. Then the site itself: speed, phones, templates. The audit is free and comes back with the three things costing you the most.

Sources
  1. Google Search Console, tobacco store, Sep 2025 to Sep 2026
  2. Disavow files built for sites we work on, 2026 (6 files, 2,227 domains)

Written Oct 25 2026. Prices and search volumes are as read on the dates stated; check them again before relying on them.

Start with the free audit

Send your site. You get the three things costing you the most traffic, the searches you should own, and a price in writing.

Free SEO audit